Shane Ense agreed to a sentence that included a 12-month driving suspension. An earlier impaired-driving conviction in the United States meant the consequences in Ontario were far more severe.
On November 6, the Ontario Court of Appeal released reasons setting aside one of his impaired-driving convictions and ordering a new trial. The case exposes a problem that a sentencing agreement alone cannot solve: another law can attach consequences that extend well beyond the penalty discussed in court.
The conviction that changed the calculation
The appeal over licensing consequences followed guilty pleas to two impaired-driving counts in April 2022 as part of a resolution covering driving and drug charges. He entered the pleas on the mistaken understanding that these would be his first impaired-driving convictions.
The American conviction changed that position. Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act triggered an indefinite suspension, rather than the 12-month restriction contemplated in the sentencing agreement.
The distinction also gives substance to comparing legal representation for DUI charges in Toronto: a review of the driving record and licensing consequences is a different task from assessing the proposed criminal sentence. Both can affect whether a person understands a resolution before accepting it.
A useful review would put the proposed sentence beside the licensing consequences and identify the assumptions behind both. If an assessment depends on a conviction being a first offence, the underlying record needs checking rather than treating the label as settled.
An uninformed plea is not automatically reversible

The Supreme Court of Canada addressed the broader problem in its 2018 decision in R. v. Wong. A valid guilty plea must be voluntary, unequivocal and informed. Relevant information can include serious legal consequences outside the criminal sentence itself.
Wong concerned immigration consequences, rather than a driving licence. The court nevertheless rejected his appeal because he had not established that knowing those consequences would have changed his decision to plead guilty.
That distinction prevents a misleading reading of the Ense result. Discovering an unwelcome consequence does not, by itself, establish a right to withdraw a plea. What the person understood and how the missing information affected the decision matter.
For someone considering a resolution, the practical question is therefore more precise than whether the sentence sounds acceptable. It is whether the decision rests on an accurate account of the consequences that matter to that person, including restrictions imposed through a separate legal process.
A new trial, with a narrower result than an acquittal
The appeal court admitted fresh evidence and ordered a new trial on one driving count. It did not acquit Ense of the allegation or erase the entire resolution. The court also corrected the record of two drug convictions to show possession rather than trafficking.
For a driver trying to understand several sets of paperwork, separating the documents is a useful starting point:
- The criminal court record identifies the conviction and sentence.
- The licensing notice identifies the restriction on driving privileges.
- The prior-conviction record supplies facts that may affect how the licensing rules apply.
Those documents answer different questions. A date stated in a sentencing discussion should not be assumed to resolve a separate licensing notice, and an appeal concerning a conviction should not be read as permission to resume driving.
The immediate outcome in Ense’s case is another trial on the affected count. For people making plea decisions now, the useful lesson comes earlier: check the records and consequences while there is still a decision to make.